Choosing the right underlayment is key to maximizing the beauty and lifespan of your hardwood floors. Whether you’re renovating or installing new flooring, the right foundation enhances comfort, reduces noise, and protects against moisture. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the best underlayment options, helping you make a smart investment for a flawless hardwood floor experience.
Underlayment for Hardwood Floors: Comparison Table
| Underlayment Type | Sound Insulation | Moisture Barrier | Thermal Insulation | Thickness Range | Eco-Friendly | Cost Level | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Felt | Good | Moderate | Good | 1/8″ – 3/16″ | Moderate | Low | Wood subfloors, moderate climates |
| Cork | Excellent | Needs pairing | Excellent | 1/8″ – 1/4″ | Yes | Moderate | Eco-conscious users, cold climates |
| Rubber | Superior | Superior | Excellent | 1/8″ – 1/4″ | Some options | High | High moisture zones, noise reduction, condos |
| Foam | Fair–Good | Decent (if built-in) | Good | 1/8″ – 1/4″ | Some | Low | Budget installs, floating floors |
| Combination (Multi-layer) | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | 1/8″ – 1/4″ | Variable | High | Demanding/complex subfloors, upstairs/noisy areas |
Everyday Usage: What Does Underlayment Do Beneath Hardwood Floors?
Underlayment acts as the “hidden hero” beneath your hardwood floors, offering a range of essential benefits in everyday use:
– Moisture Protection: Prevents damaging moisture from reaching your hardwood, reducing the risk of warping, cupping, or mold.
– Noise Reduction: Damps footfall and limits echo between floors, making your space quieter—especially important in multi-level homes and apartments.
– Thermal Insulation: Adds a layer of warmth underfoot by inhibiting transfer of cold from subfloors like concrete.
– Comfort and Support: Makes hardwood floors a bit softer and more forgiving, which can be especially noticeable for standing and walking.
– Subfloor Smoothing: Cushions small imperfections, helping to create a more level surface for your finished floor.
– Longevity: Reduces wear and tear by managing expansion and contraction, and buffering impact.
Depending on the material, some underlayment types can also combat bacteria, impede allergens, or allow just enough “breathability” so minor trapped moisture doesn’t build up.
Benefits of Choosing the Right Underlayment
1. Protects Your Investment
High-quality hardwood isn’t cheap. The right underlayment shields it from moisture, temperature swings, and structural movement, helping ensure your flooring lasts for decades.
2. Improves Acoustics
The underlayment you choose directly affects how noise travels—both in your room (echo, tapping) and to the level below (impact footstep sound). Some products excel at sound absorption, making them perfect for apartments, bedrooms, or nurseries.
3. Enhances Comfort and Warmth
While hardwood is beautiful, it can be hard and cold, especially over concrete. Underlayment adds subtle cushioning and acts as a thermal break, making bare feet and long days on your feet more pleasant.
4. Adds Stability and Smoothness
Underlayment absorbs minor subfloor irregularities—helping prevent future drooping or uneven boards. This means a better-looking and longer-lasting finished floor.
5. Increases Energy Efficiency
R-value (how well a material resists heat flow) may not seem glamorous, but it helps your floors stay warmer, especially in winter months, contributing to a more comfortable, energy-efficient home.
How to Choose the Best Underlayment for Hardwood Floors
Selecting the best underlayment depends on several factors unique to your home and flooring:
1. Subfloor Type
- Plywood/Wood Subfloor: Breathable underlayments (like felt or cork) are ideal, allowing both hardwood and subfloor to “breathe.”
- Concrete Subfloor: Impermeable underlayments with a built-in vapor barrier (like rubber, combination synthetic, or foam with vapor backing) are required to prevent moisture migration.
- Uneven/Damaged Subfloor: Flexible underlayments can help even out small imperfections; but repair major issues before installation.
2. Climate and Room Use
- Basement or Slab: High moisture risk means you need a robust moisture barrier.
- Cold Room: Higher R-value materials like cork or certain composites add warmth.
- Upper Floors/Condos: Prioritize sound insulation (look for high IIC and STC ratings).
- Radiant Heat: Avoid underlayments with asphalt; select one with a lower R-value for efficient heat transfer and moisture control compatibility.
3. Hardwood Floor Type
- Solid Hardwood: Can use a variety of underlayments, but pay close attention to manufacturer requirements (especially regarding moisture and compression resistance).
- Engineered Hardwood: Typically more forgiving, but still requires proper underlayment suited to install type (floating vs. nail-down or glue-down).
4. Thickness and Compression Resistance
- Appropriate Thickness: 1/8″ (3mm) is standard; 3/16″ provides a good balance of comfort and support. Too thick can compromise stability, too thin reduces benefits.
- Compression Resistance: Should maintain thickness under furniture and traffic (look for high-density or specified compression rating).
5. Special Requirements
- Allergies/Eco-friendliness: Cork is natural, antimicrobial, and sustainable.
- Budget: Foam offers the lowest cost; felt and cork offer a cost-effective balance of performance and price.
- Building Code: For multi-story dwellings, check required acoustic ratings (IIC/STC) before purchase.
User Tips & Best Practices
1. Always Prepare the Subfloor
Make sure your subfloor is smooth, clean, dry, and free of debris. Minor imperfections can be covered by flexible underlayment, but fix major issues up front.
2. Mind the Moisture
For wood over concrete, always use an underlayment with a vapor barrier. In really wet basements, consider an additional moisture membrane.
3. Overlap and Seal Seams
Underlayments should be installed with all seams overlapped and sealed with manufacturer-approved tape. This ensures continuity of the moisture and sound barriers.
4. Follow Manufacturer Guidelines
Always check both the hardwood and underlayment manufacturer’s recommendations for compatibility, allowed types, thickness, and installation method.
5. Don’t Skimp on Thickness or Quality
Underlayments are inexpensive compared to the cost of the flooring itself. It pays to invest in quality, reputable products.
6. Choose the Right Underlayment for the Install Method
- Floating Floors: Opt for underlayments suitable for floating installations (typically foam, cork, or combo).
- Glued-Down Floors: Use underlayments rated for glue-down; often cork or rubber.
- Nail-Down Floors: Felt is traditional, but make sure it meets updated specs.
7. Account for Finished Floor Height
Add underlayment thickness to your flooring thickness to ensure compatibility with doors, trim, and transitions.
Technical Features Comparison Table
| Feature / Type | Felt | Cork | Rubber | Foam | Multi-Layer/Synthetic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moisture Protection | Moderate (some are vapor retarders) | Low (needs vapor barrier) | Excellent (built-in barrier) | Moderate–Good (some built-in vapor rating <0.7) | Excellent (<0.7 perm) |
| Thickness | 1/8″–3/16″ | 1/8″–1/4″ | 1/8″–1/4″ | 1/8″–1/4″ | 1/8″–3/16″ |
| Sound (IIC/STC) | 60–67 | 60–68 | 60–70+ | 60–67 | 66–71+ |
| R-Value (Thermal) | 0.33–0.6 | ~0.5–0.6 | 0.6+ | ~0.3 | 0.5–0.6 |
| Compression Resistance (kPa) | 16–30 | 18–30 | 30+ | 16–30 | 16–30+ |
| Eco-Friendliness | Yes (often recycled) | Yes (natural, renewable) | Some (varies) | Moderate (recycled available) | Variable |
| Subfloor Fit | Wood, some over concrete | Any (needs barrier over concrete) | Any | Any | Any |
| Cost | $ | $$ | $$$ | $ | $$$ |
Top Underlayment Types Explained
Felt Underlayment
Best for: Wood subfloors (nail-down solid hardwood), basic moisture protection, sound absorption.
- Made from recycled fibers, felt is dense and provides solid sound reduction.
- Provides basic moisture “retardation” (not a waterproof barrier).
- Good for traditional hardwood over plywood subfloors.
- Inexpensive and easy to install—typically stapled.
- Not suited for installations over concrete or high moisture areas without an added moisture barrier.
User Tip: Combine with a vapor barrier for damp zones or basements.
Cork Underlayment
Best for: Soundproofing, eco-friendliness, thermal insulation, floating or glue-down installations.
- Natural, renewable, and antimicrobial.
- Excellent in absorbing sound and insulating against temperature change.
- Defense against mold/mildew.
- Does NOT block water well alone; pair with a separate vapor barrier over concrete.
- Easy to install, but more costly than felt or foam.
User Tip: Choose 1/4″ cork for maximum thermal and acoustic performance in bedrooms, studios, or upper floors.
Rubber Underlayment
Best for: Superior sound and moisture protection in high-traffic, multi-family, or commercial areas.
- Provides both serious moisture resistance and acoustic benefits.
- Excellent compression strength and durability.
- Often made using recycled rubber.
- More expensive and sometimes heavier to work with.
- Suitable for concrete or wood subfloors.
User Tip: Check if your flooring manufacturer recommends/approves rubber for your hardwood type.
Foam Underlayment
Best for: Budget projects, floating floors, light moisture protection.
- Inexpensive, lightweight, and easy to install.
- Can come with integrated vapor barrier.
- Provides decent noise reduction and some cushioning, but can compress permanently over time.
- Less suitable for glued/nail-down installations or under heavy furniture without high density rating.
User Tip: Upgrade to high-density foam with vapor barrier for concrete subfloors or high foot-traffic.
Combination/Multi-Layer Synthetic Underlayment
Best for: Maximum moisture, sound, and thermal performance in homes with demanding requirements.
- Products like QuietWalk, FloorMuffler, and other premium brands offer built-in vapor barriers, acoustic layers, and superior compression resistance.
- Typically made for floating or engineered hardwood floors.
- Tight perm and high IIC/STC and R-value ratings.
- Higher price, but offers an “all-in-one” solution.
User Tip: Look for IIC/STC above 65 for superior acoustics in apartments and high-density dwellings.
Practical Tips for Selecting and Using Underlayment
- Confirm Compatibility: Always check if your hardwood flooring is compatible with the underlayment material and thickness.
- Mind the Vapor Barrier: Over concrete or in basements, a dedicated vapor barrier is not optional—it’s essential.
- Prioritize Acoustic Rating (IIC/STC): If living in a condo or multi-level home, choose products with verified acoustic ratings suited to building codes.
- ECO Friendly?: Cork and many recycled rubber underlayments are great for reducing environmental impact.
- Account for Finished Floor Height: Include both hardwood and underlayment thickness in door and trim planning.
- Preparation is Key: Remove debris, fill low spots, and let both flooring and underlayment acclimate in the install space before beginning.
- Professional Advice: When in doubt, ask a flooring installer or retailer—especially for unusual subfloor conditions or radiant heat setups.
Related Video
Conclusion
Selecting the best underlayment for hardwood floors is a critical, often overlooked step that impacts your floor’s comfort, durability, performance, and even appearance. Each type—felt, cork, rubber, foam, or multi-layer composite—offers unique advantages suited for different environments, budgets, and flooring systems.
Whether your priority is moisture protection, sound reduction, thermal insulation, eco-friendliness, or ease of installation, taking the time to match the right underlayment to your subfloor, room use, and hardwood type will safeguard your investment and deliver daily comfort and peace of mind.
Follow best practices by considering your subfloor, climate, and building requirements, and don’t hesitate to combine underlayment types (like cork plus a vapor barrier) in tough environments. The right foundation isn’t just under your floor—it’s under your enjoyment, too.
FAQ
What does underlayment actually do for hardwood floors?
Underlayment is a thin layer between your hardwood flooring and subfloor. It provides moisture protection, reduces noise, increases thermal comfort, smooths minor imperfections, and prolongs the life and appearance of your hardwood floor.
Is underlayment always required when installing hardwood floors?
While some installations (like nailed-down floors over perfect plywood) may get by without underlayment, it’s almost always a good idea. For floating or engineered hardwood, or when installing over concrete, an underlayment is essential for performance and warranty protection.
What’s the best underlayment for hardwood floors over concrete?
Look for impermeable underlayments with a built-in vapor barrier, such as rubber, specialized synthetic pads, or foam with attached vapor barrier. Pairing cork with an additional vapor sheet also works.
Can I use carpet padding as an underlayment for hardwood?
No. Carpet padding is too soft, will compress over time, lacks a moisture barrier, and can cause movement or squeaks. Use materials designed specifically for hardwood floors.
How thick should underlayment be for hardwood floors?
Typically, 1/8″ (3mm) is standard. Up to 1/4″ is fine for cork or foam, but going thicker may cause instability. Thickness should also match your flooring and subfloor requirements.
Does underlayment help with sound insulation between floors?
Yes. Underlayments with high Impact Insulation Class (IIC) and Sound Transmission Class (STC) ratings minimize both impact and airborne noise, greatly improving sound insulation between floors.
Which is the most eco-friendly underlayment?
Cork underlayment is the top choice for eco-friendliness. It’s a natural, renewable resource and also offers antimicrobial benefits. Many felt and rubber products are also partially recycled.
What if my subfloor is uneven?
Flexible underlayments like high-density foam or rubber can absorb minor imperfections, but major dips or high spots should be repaired before installation for optimum results.
Can underlayment be used with radiant floor heating?
Yes, but avoid underlayments with asphalt. Use low R-value, moisture-resistant, heat-safe materials. Always check manufacturer compatibility for both flooring and underlayment.
Do I need a moisture barrier if my subfloor is plywood (not concrete)?
If you’re above grade and in a dry climate, a moisture barrier may not be essential. However, in humid zones or ground-level installations, an additional vapor barrier adds protection and is strongly recommended.